The Siren of Paris by David LeRoy

In The Siren of Paris by David LeRoy, Marc is tempted by the siren call of Paris to return to the place of his birth, a place he does not remember but has the enticements of all he desires: love and art. Set in the time before Paris is invaded by Germans during WWII, LeRoy does well in depicting by turns the fear and the indifference Parisians and expats felt when Germany began to advance across Europe.  Once France begins to realize that negotiations with Germany will amount to nothing and Germany begins to take more territory, the fears become overwhelming for many, and there is an anxiousness that pervades the novel’s pages, especially as Marc’s friends panic about returning to the United States and England.

With that said, there are quite a few missed opportunities in the beginning of this novel when Marc is on a diplomatic mission with Mr. Wells (at the behest of William Bullitt, US ambassador to France) and they meet with not only Mussolini, but also Ribbentrop, who goes on a diatribe for 2 hours, and you don’t get any of the conversations!  Instead, LeRoy spends several pages on news reel footage in the local theater afterward when Marc returns and is on a date with Marie.  Missed opportunities like these set off alarm bells that more research could have been done to learn what might have been said by these high-ranking officials conquering Europe.  It also begs the question of whether this story was as well thought out as it could have been, especially given that the transitions between moments in time and locations are often left out and the reader feels adrift until they get their bearings again as to where they are, what day, and whom they encounter.

LeRoy does have a firm grasp of how to make the plot move along and how to make the reader feel the fear of the Parisians and the expats who are fleeing the city as the German’s approach.  From the overflowing train platforms to the rush out of their apartments with their clothes on their backs, the plot moves along quickly and ramps up the tension.  As Marc seeks to leave at the last minute, his friends Dora, Nigel, and David are not forgotten by the narration as their paths homeward are highlighted as well.  However, in many ways, LeRoy has sketched the character of Dora (a subordinate character) better than he has the main protagonist, Marc.

The Siren of Paris by David LeRoy had the potential to be a great novel, but with the poor plot transitions and missed opportunities for historical information and additional characterization, it becomes a chore to read.  The additional framing in the novel at the beginning and end in which Marc is reviewing his life in flashes and the colors of his soul are changing read a bit overly dramatic and take away from the rest of the story.  With so many styles and techniques running amok in this novel, it is hard for readers to feel fully engaged in the story or connected to Marc.  Unfortunately, this reader didn’t even make it halfway through the novel before deciding she’d had enough.  However, if readers are willing to overlook these issues and focus on the fast-paced plot, it could be an enjoyable read for those that like WWII novels.

About the Author:

In writing his first novel, The Siren of Paris, David LeRoy drew upon his longtime interest in philosophy, the visual arts, myth, storytelling, psychology, and Ocean Liner travel. During a visit to France to study art in the fall of 2012, LeRoy became intrigued by the French Resistance, particularly when his research revealed the role of Americans in the Resistance, as well as the limited means of escape from Europe as the war escalated. LeRoy holds a bachelor of arts in philosophy and religion.

This is my 66th book for the New Authors Reading Challenge 2012.


  1. Serena, Thank you for the great review. You have raised some points which no one else has yet drawn attention to in part one. The sumner wells trip had several challenges. Ballanceing Marc, and Wells against the “others,” who can upstage everything, was not easy. Historically, Mr. Wells trip actually was a disaster, hence his drinking which was his habit as well as others on trains. And research, well, I had too much at times. This book could have exploded in size but I choose instead a faster pace. With that said, these past several reviews have been incredibly helpful, because I want to avoid these problems in future work. I am not certain yet if there will be a sequal to this book, however I am looking into it. I do not wish to just repeate the same structure and pacing going into the next one, because the story of Marie’s betrayal during the purge after the war is different than Marc’s during the war. The Siren of Paris has worked for many readers, but I think repeating this style of writing for Marie would be a mistake. So, everyting said is a tramendous help and I am thankfu for your thoughts.

    • I’m glad that the review helped you in some way. I think the novel has great potential to draw in readers, but there were things I wished there had been a greater focus on and Marc was to easily upstaged by other characters.

  2. V nice review — you know how I felt about this one — some good potential and inventive plot/narrative technique — but I didn’t connect with Marc.

  3. I too thought it has potential. It’s rough, needs sprucing up. After I posted my review the author visited and left a very nice comment. If you have time read it.

  4. Since it’s a chore to read, I think I’ll pass. Thanks for the review!

  5. Sounds like we had similar thoughts about this one.