Guest Review: My Ántonia by Willa Cather

USbooksNebraskaFebruary is the second month of the United States of Books (click here for further details).

The United States of Books: the State of Nebraska

Today’s review is from Teri at Sportochick’s Musings.

My Ántonia (Great Plains Trilogy #3) by Willa Cather

MyAntoniaBlurb ~ 

Through Jim Burden’s endearing, smitten voice, we revisit the remarkable vicissitudes of immigrant life in the Nebraska heartland, with all its insistent bonds. Guiding the way are some of literature’s most beguiling characters: the Russian brothers plagued by memories of a fateful sleigh ride, Antonia’s desperately homesick father and self-indulgent mother, and the coy Lena Lingard. Holding the pastoral society’s heart, of course, is the bewitching, free-spirited Antonia.


Review ~ ★ ★ 1/2

This story is narrated in first person by Jim Burden in what I think is a very plain unemotional manner. I honestly had a hard time reading this book and at points kept putting it down. It was puzzling to me that for all of the unusual dramatic events in this book it was for me unemotional. I am not sure if listening to it on Audible and switching off and on with the book impacted my feelings. Though these dramatic events in the book were described in fine detail my mind felt a distance from the writing.

Two characters did stand out. Antonia who was very expressive and Jim’s grandfather for the ways that he dealt with crisis’s, personality issues and his deep integrity. Antonia throughout the book was very emotional and it was obvious to see why quiet Jim liked to be around her and had grown to love her.

I finally connected with the book in the last chapter and a half where it became to me a book worth reading. This part of the book make me feel great sadness for Jim and Antonia and where they were 20 years later. The ending was poignant and still brings tears to my eyes.

This book leaves the readers pondering the what if. What if Jim didn’t go away to college? What if Antonia made a different decision when her first love deceived her? What if Jim had told her he loved her? But the largest question that I had was how did Jim love Antonia? A sister, friend, lover? This book left me feeling sad because if Jim had more gumption his life would of been so different than it was. It also left me pondering on how many people lost out on the best thing of their lives because they were afraid.

Find the Book At Amazon | Barnes & Noble | Goodreads

  • Suko

    I enjoyed this brief guest review. I read this many years ago. I might pick it up again in the future, especially if I could locate my copy.

  • Anna (Diary of an Eccentric)

    I never got around to reading this book, and with this reviewer only connecting with the story at the very end, I’m not inclined to pick it up anytime soon.

  • I recently read a fantastic book set in Nebraska in 1900, if you are interested: The Bones of Paradise by Jonis Agee. I had no idea about all the sand dunes in Nebraska (the “sandhills”). But that was only the beginning of what I learned in that book. Very good fiction.

    • Sounds like a good read. This is a project based on Entertainment Weekly’s list of books for all 50 states.